top of page

Jeffrey Rosen on Classical Virtue, SCOTUS, and Advice for Successor Hiram Chodosh

4 minutes ago
12 min read

The Forum sits down with Jeffrey Rosen, CEO emeritus at the National Constitution Center


Image credit: Simon and Schuster
Image credit: Simon and Schuster

Sarah McPeek: Hello, and welcome to The Forum’s interview series, sponsored by the Salvatori Center. Today, we are here with Jeffrey Rosen, the CEO emeritus at the National Constitution Center, a senior fellow at the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, a professor of law at The George Washington University and a New York Times best-selling author. On top of that, he is the soon-to-be Founding Director of the National Institute for the Constitution and Civic Virtue. Thank you for talking with us.


Jeffrey Rosen: Wonderful to be here.


Caleb Zylstra: You've written a pair of books titled The Pursuit of Happiness and The Pursuit of Liberty, but the Declaration only pairs the word ‘pursuit’ with happiness. Why did you choose to extend that notion to liberty?


Jeffrey Rosen: Great question — mostly because it seemed like such a good title. ‘The pursuit of happiness’ is such a famous phrase, and the second book is about how the battle between Hamilton and Jefferson has defined all of American history, in particular, their battles over the balance between liberty and security. So I thought, “Why not pursue liberty?” And then it became a trilogy, and we needed a third pursuit, and that will be the pursuit of union, which is in the middle of [being written] and will be coming out probably next year.


Sarah McPeek: In The Pursuit of Happiness, you write about how the Founders considered the pursuit of happiness as the pursuit of virtue. But the Founders themselves were at times very viceful: [Take] for example, Jefferson’s infamous extravagance and unchastity. I’m curious how we should think about the relationship between the ideals they articulated and the lives they led. 


Jeffrey Rosen: We know the many ways that the Founders failed to live up to their own ideals. In particular, as you say, the notorious stain of slavery. What’s striking about the Founders is not that they failed in some cases to live up to their ideals, but that they struggled so mindfully to do better, and were very self-aware in many cases when they fell short. They constantly wrote diaries and letters and had conversations about their daily efforts to be more virtuous, and were often beating themselves up when they fell short of their own ideals. 


On the question of slavery, it's striking that none of the enslavers of the founding generation defended slavery. All said that it was inconsistent with the Bible and natural law, and yet many relied on enslaved labor. And in the case of Jefferson, because of his extreme addiction to expensive living and his refusal to give up the lifestyle, he betrayed his ideals more than many. There’s a speech that Patrick Henry gave that kind of summed up both their self awareness and their hypocrisy. After he says, “Give me liberty or give me death,” Patrick Henry said, “Is it not amazing that I myself, who believes that slavery violates the Bible and natural law, owns slaves? I won't justify it. I won't attempt to. It's simple avarice or greed. I can’t do with the inconvenience of living without it.” That really was the heart of the matter for many of them. 


Of course, the most significant gift that the Founders gave us are these inspiring documents of the American ideal that both held them to account when they failed to blow up their ideals and empowered future generations of others who'd been excluded from the original promise of We the People to insist on their inclusion. It was starting with African Americans like Benjamin Banneker, who wrote to Thomas Jefferson upbraiding him for leaving African Americans out of the promise of the Declaration, all the way up to Dr. King on the Mall, who talked about the Declaration as a promissory note.


Sarah McPeek: What differences are there between the classical understandings of virtue that you talk about — Cicero in particular — and virtue according to the Founders? What else are they considering?


Jeffrey Rosen: The classical conception could be distilled in the classical virtues, which are prudence, temperance, courage, and justice. The Founders were also moved by the Bible and by Christian philosophers, thinkers, and theologians, and the theological virtues of faith, hope, and charity were ones that some embraced openly. Others were less openly theistic or less traditional in their Christianity. But strikingly, all of the major Founders were believers of some kind and thought that faith was compatible with reason. It’s really striking how, at that moment in the Enlightenment, Christian thinkers like Woollettson and Tillotson and and George Whitfield, the great evangelical preacher, as well as social contract theorists like John Locke and John Milton, all of whom were essentially Christian in their view of the social contract, believed that the duty to be virtuous was one to align oneself with God, which was also the Stoic view. 


The great American innovation or contribution to the debate over faith was the idea of religious liberty and religious pluralism that Thomas Jefferson and James Madison articulated when they opposed religious establishments in Virginia. Madison, in his memorial and remonstrance against religious assessments, said that freedom of conscience was an unalienable right because the opinions of men, being dependent on evidence contemplated by their own minds, cannot be controlled by others. In other words, “I can’t give either of you the power to control my thoughts, they’re the product of reason and persuasion, not force or violence.”


That was why Madison wanted an amendment to the Constitution [forbidding] the states as well as the federal government from infringing freedom of conscience, which would have immediately banned all of the many states that continued to have religious establishments. There were many who disagreed with Madison, such as Roger Sherman of Connecticut, a Puritan theocrat who defended the Congregationalist establishment in Connecticut, who thought that virtue was cultivated in covenanted communities of the born again. In the end, Madison won the debate because the free exercise clause and the establishment clause were put into the Constitution and ultimately incorporated against the states after the passage of the 14th Amendment. 


Caleb Zylstra: You mentioned the difference between classical understandings of virtue and virtue according to the Founders as being a difference that comes from the fact that the Founders’ ideas on virtue were sort of filtered through a Christian worldview. How do you think those ideas should be looked at by people who come from different religious traditions?


Jeffrey Rosen: The great shining inspiration of the founding was one of religious pluralism, and it was crucial that the first words in the First Amendment, our Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion. When when Vice President JD Vance said that America was and always had been a Christian nation, Justice Neil Gorsuch was correct to say, “We have a First Amendment, for goodness sake, no establishment of religion.” Justice Gorsuch was accurately stating the fact that the Founders rejected the idea that America could be defined by any religion. Instead, we are defined by the American creed, as represented in the Declaration. The fact the Founders were Christian didn’t in any way deviate from their classical understanding: Remember, the Christian writers from Locke and Milton to the theologians all were classicists, and all of them quoted books like Cicero's Tusculan Disputations as the essence of their understanding of civic virtue. 


The glory of America, and the reason that Jefferson was right to put the Virginia Bill of Religious Freedom on his tombstone as one of his greatest accomplishments, is that our Founders believed that truth has nothing to fear from error as long as reason is free to combat it, and that's why they insisted that people should have a full range of opinions about religion and politics, including false opinions, so that they could have the character and independence of thought to reject them and to converge on the truth. The Founders were fearless in their belief that the truth could emerge in the marketplace of ideas.

Justice Robert Jackson put this more beautifully than anyone else in his opinion, striking down compulsory flag salutes for Jehovah’s Witnesses. He said, in even more beautiful language than I’ll paraphrase from memory, “If there’s any fixed star in our constitutional constellation, it’s that no official high or petty shall be allowed to prescribe what shall be orthodox in matters of faith or belief,” and that is indeed the American way.


Caleb Zylstra: I’d like to ask you a little bit about court jurisprudence, and in particular about originalism. Originalism has, for many years, been understood as a right-wing judicial philosophy. Still, figures like Yale Law Professor Akhil Reed Amar have led a push for those on the left to embrace originalism, and Justice Jackson stated in her confirmation hearings that her decisions are based on what the text meant to those who wrote it. Do you think there's a future for a more left-wing originalist jurisprudence?


Jeffrey Rosen: I had the fortune of studying with Akhil Amar more than 30 years ago, and back then he insisted that originalism, honestly applied, could lead to liberal as well as conservative results. I think it’s fair to say that for most of the past 30 years, he didn't have an awful lot of acolytes on the on the left, because many liberals felt that originalism was being applied inconsistently by judges who were picking among text, history, and tradition in order to reach preferred results. Once originalists got a clear majority on the Supreme Court, things changed, and whether you like originalism or not, it’s now necessary to make arguments in terms of text, history, and tradition, in order to attempt to win arguments. It was more than a decade ago that then-Dean Elena Kagan of Harvard Law School said in a tribute to Justice Scalia, “We're all originalists now.” 


There are very live debates among originalists, including the conservative justices themselves, about which originalist methodology to stress. Justice Gorsuch is more of a textualist. Justice Barrett cares more about original public meaning, as well as what she calls ‘liquidation,’ which means the evolving understanding of a particular clause after ratification. During an interview with Justice Barrett about her new book, I asked her what to make of the fact that originalism had originally been presented as something that would do two things: constrain judicial discretion and lead to judicial deference to democratic policy results.


I suggested that it hadn’t succeeded in those promises, given the malleability of history and the fact that the new watchword among many conservatives is ‘judicial engagement’ rather than ‘judicial restraint,’ by which they mean it’s okay to strike down a whole bunch of laws if they violate text and history. Justice Barrett, with admirable candor, responded that it was true that originalism hadn't proved successful in entirely constraining judges or leading to deference — but that it was the best methodology because at least it rooted our arguments in text and history, which are legal tools as opposed to non-legal ones like moral philosophy or natural law. 


Interestingly, some originalists now are appealing to natural law, such as Randy Barnett, who says that in cases where the text is unclear, natural law should rule. They make claims about the Founders themselves having resorted to that interpretive tool, claims that are entirely contested. In my view, there is no single original public meaning of nearly all of the contested laws of clauses of the Constitution that end up before the Supreme Court: All of their meaning was essentially contested from the beginning, and for me, it all goes back to the initial battles between Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson.


Regardless of whether you think originalism is a good thing, it’s an exciting time to be a student of law and a student of history because you need to make arguments in historical terms, and to do that, you’ve got to learn a lot of history. That’s why I love teaching constitutional law at this particular moment in history.


Caleb Zylstra: You mentioned interviewing Justice Barrett for a book of hers. Justice Alito is currently on a press tour for his new book, and he’s far from the only justice to have done that. How should we think about sitting justices as public intellectuals, and how do you think fame and the judiciary interact?


Jeffrey Rosen: It's remarkable how much things have changed since I started writing about the court. In the early 1990s I had the incredible break of becoming the legal affairs editor of The New Republic magazine. It was a small group of journalists who talked to the justices, and the justices generally didn't grant interviews of any kind. The norm was that the justices should remain like mysterious and inaccessible figures in order to maintain their authority. The social theorist Max Weber said that authority requires mystery, and just as the British monarchy used to cultivate that kind of distance and mystery, that’s what justices did. 


Things completely changed, [and] I don’t know exactly when it happened. Justice Thomas may have had the first bestseller, My Grandfather's Son. He both got a large advance and it was a huge hit. Writing books is one of the only ways that the justices are allowed to supplement their income, so you can understand why they have an incentive to to write best-selling memoirs with large advances, and with the multiplicity of media platforms, they can now speak directly to the public by writing op-eds, or choose interviewers they like at whatever venues they want. Is it a good or bad thing? It’s up to people to decide. Some will think that this is good to have more transparency, others say that this encourages the justices to stray into politics. They do tend to speak to friendly audiences: Justice Alito spoke at the Federalist Society dinner in D.C., which I had the pleasure of attending, and it was a friendly house, of course. 


The one thing I do think the court has been wise to resist is TV. It was conventional wisdom that there should be cameras in the courtroom for a long time. Justice Scalia adamantly opposed it on the grounds that snippets would be taken out of context and people would misunderstand the arguments because they wouldn’t take the time to listen to the whole thing. Justice Scalia said if you could have a federal marshal in every home with a gun to people's head as they watch C-SPAN, and not allow them to get up until the argument was over, he might be okay with it. The courts came up with a good compromise, I think, which is to issue same-day audio and transcripts of the arguments. So one bit of mystery that the court is maintaining is not actually televising the arguments. But beyond that, I think the justices are just as eager to sell memoirs nowadays as every other public official.


Sarah McPeek: You left the National Constitution Center earlier this year, and they have now hired former CMC President Hiram Chodosh. Do you have any advice for President Chodosh on how to approach this role?


Jeffrey Rosen: I was delighted to see that. President Chodosh and I were law school contemporaries, and I’ve followed his career with great admiration ever since. I wouldn't presume to advise him — he did such a great job at Claremont McKenna. But, I do think that the National Constitution Center has a precious trust and legitimacy in America that was cultivated over the past decade by bringing together liberals and conservatives to talk about the Constitution on all platforms, focusing on constitutional rather than political issues. I found that people are not likely to agree when they talk about politics, and it’s not all that productive to have those debates. But when you talk about the Constitution, you need to learn something before you can have an informed opinion. 


It’s inspiring to see how Americans, starting at a very young age, are able to rise to the occasion of thinking like constitutional lawyers. I loved the moment on a Zoom when I encouraged the middle school audience to read the majority opinions as well as the dissents. And one kid in the chat said, “I’m Bill. I'm 11. I don’t know that I could read the dissent.” I said, “I know you can, Bill.” He did and was able to distill the essence of it really well. It’s just so inspiring to go around the country and see the hunger in this country for balanced constitutional discourse, [and] the patriotism and fervor that Americans of all perspectives in red and blue states embrace the Declaration and the Constitution [with]. 


We need the productive tension between the ideals of Hamilton and Jefferson, between liberal and strict construction, between national power and states’ rights, in order to maintain the American idea itself. It’s on the rare occasions when extremes on the left and the right have rejected the American idea entirely that the shooting has begun. It’s a privilege to be part of constitutional debate in America and to provide platforms that host these thoughtful conversations that inspire lifelong learning. The pursuit of happiness for the Founders meant being a lifelong learner, and I’m so gratified that people are hungry to learn about our Founding ideals and to apply them in their own lives. That’s why it’s such a privilege to be involved in constitutional education. So I wish President Chodosh the very best, and look forward to our work together in the years ahead.


Sarah McPeek:

You’re now entering a role as the founding director of the National Institute for the Constitution and Civic Virtue. Civic centers are very in vogue right now, but they are also accused of partisanship. I’m curious how you think we can fashion a version of civics that has broad appeal.


Jeffrey Rosen: It is urgently important to bring together real liberals and real conservatives, not with the goal of some kumbaya agreement or even a moderate consensus about politics, but for civil dialogue and debate. The Founders thought so, and they believed that unless we learn the habits of civil dialogue to disagree without being disagreeable, we’d go the way of Greece and Rome. That’s why George Washington, in his many messages to Congress, and in his last, including his last one, championed the founding of a national university in Washington D.C. that would teach the principles of the science of government, the principles of the Constitution, and the habits of civil dialogue.


There are just so few enclaves of reason in America today, largely thanks to our social media environment, which is based on a business model of ‘enrage to engage’ in algorithmic filter bubbles and echo chambers, which give people more and more extreme versions of what they already believe. The role of civic centers, universities, constitution centers, and institutes — at their best — is to provide truly neutral platforms for constitutional conversations that will lead people to learn from each other, and in some cases, perhaps even to change their minds.


Sarah McPeek: Thank you!

 
 

The Forum is the Claremont Colleges’ open-submission paper featuring thoughtful and incisive commentary.

  • Instagram
The Forum Logo (the thinker)

Sponsored by Claremont McKenna's Salvatori Center for the Study of Individual Freedom

Unless otherwise noted, pieces reflect the opinions of the authors and not the opinions of The Forum or the Salvatori Center

bottom of page